Does Size Matter When It Comes to Title VII Sexual Harassment Suits?

The issue of civil rights has always been hotly contested in this country. Heated debates resulted in the passage of the landmark Civil Rights Act of 1964. Originally intended to secure the rights of African Americans, it was later amended to safeguard women’s rights.

Title VII of this law prohibits discrimination in employment on the basis of race, national origin, gender, or religion. In the late 1970s courts began ruling that it applied to sexual harassment as well. Though Title VII only applies to employers with fifteen or more employees, it is how the definition of employee bears on the case that is the center of the most significant controvery regarding discrimination suits.

Consider the case of Jenifer Arbaugh vs. Y&H Corp. The suit involves an employee of the Moonlight CafГ(c) in New Orleans who alleged she was victimized by a sexually hostile work environment while employed as a bartender and waitress. Y&H Corp., a corporation with two individual owners, owned the Moonlight CafГ(c). The case was tried in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana, and in 2002, a jury awarded Arbaugh $40,000 in damages.

Y&H Corp filed a motion, arguing the action should be dismissed because the federal court had no jurisdiction as the company had less than 15 employees, which meant Title VII didn’t apply. The methodology they used in determining the number of employees involved excluding the two owners, their wives, who also worked for the business, and their delivery truck drivers.

In 2003, the district court agreed with Y&H Corp and dismissed the case on the grounds of subject matter jurisdiction. That is they agreed that given the number of employees was less than 15, the court had no authority to decide on the case. A year later, a three-judge panel of the U.S. 5th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the district court’s 2003 decision.

However, Arbaugh made an appeal to the Supreme Court and it began hearing arguments on January 11, 2006. The basis of the appeal is that Section 701(b) of Title VII does, in fact, state that the prohibition against employment discrimination applies to employers with fifteen or more employees. The question is whether this provision also limits the subject matter jurisdiction of the federal courts as was previously decided, or does it only raise an issue about the merits of a Title VII claim? Arbaugh’s attorney argued that the number of employees went to the merits of the case, rather than to the question of whether or not the court had the right to rule.

What stands at the heart of this case is whether the definition of an employee is decided as one of the facts of the case or as determination of the court’s authority. This decision has profound implications for employers. If the definition of an employee is a deciding factor in the court’s right to rule, an employee can postpone raising the question of who are the legitimate employees of the company being sued until after he/she knows the outcome of a trial on the case’s merits. This means a suit of this type can drag on costing the company being sued millions of dollars in legal fees. If the definition of an employee is determined to be part of the merits of the case, than a jury would decide on that factor along with the rest of the case’s merits, which would expedite litigation.

The Supreme Court is expected to decide on this issue as part of their ruling in the Arbaugh case.

13,467 thoughts on “Does Size Matter When It Comes to Title VII Sexual Harassment Suits?

  1. buy cialis online with discover card
    [url=]cialis at walmart
    [/url] viagra cialis combined
    cialis walmart
    – cialis in weston-super-mare
    cialis vs viagra pharmacology

  2. Greetings from Idaho! I’m bored to tears at work so I decided to check out your site on my iphone during lunch
    break. I love the info you present here and can’t wait to take a look when I get
    home. I’m surprised at how fast your blog loaded on my
    mobile .. I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G ..
    Anyhow, superb site!
    cbn cannabis oil

  3. Die Zahl der Todesfälle durch COVID-19 in Italien ist um 66 gestiegen, gegenüber 43 am Vortag, sagte die Katastrophenschutzbehörde,
    während die tägliche Zahl der neuen Fälle von 329 am Mittwoch leicht auf 333 angestiegen ist.

    Die Weltgesundheitsorganisation hat bekannt gegeben, dass
    die Prüfung des Malariamedikaments Hydroxychloroquin in ihrer großen Mehrländerstudie zur Behandlung von COVID-19-Patienten eingestellt wurde,
    nachdem neue Daten und Studien keinen Nutzen zeigten.

  4. Знаете ли вы?
    Владелец вернул похищенную картину Пикассо почтой, не найдя покупателей.
    Жену Генриха VIII на суде защищал посол Священной Римской империи.
    Убийца с руками-клешнями избежал тюрьмы, но позже сам был убит.
    Будущего чемпиона Европы по боксу в детстве одновременно дразнили «хохлом» и «москалём».
    Консервативные художественные критики обрушились на портрет девушки, называя её гермафродитом, дочерью Каина и проституткой.


  5. Wow quite a lot of superb advice. viagra
    [url=]v75qgym b329jo[/url] 357_21a

  6. I know this if off topic but I’m looking into starting my own weblog and was wondering what all is needed
    to get set up? I’m assuming having a blog like yours would cost
    a pretty penny? I’m not very internet smart so I’m not 100%
    sure. Any recommendations or advice would be greatly appreciated.
    royal seed cbd oil

  7. [url=]sildenafil 100mg[/url] [url=]levitra 5mg uk[/url] [url=]ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets[/url]

  8. Useful information. Fortunate me I discovered your website unintentionally,
    and I am stunned why this twist of fate did not took place earlier!
    I bookmarked it.

  9. Model plugged in Casino web sites along chock-full commission – [url=]mgm grand casino [/url]
    sunset station casino
    best sports bets today

    particular frosting for unusual member

  10. I used to be suggested this website by mmy cousin. I amm now not
    positive whether or nott this put up is written through him as no one else recognize such particular about my problem.
    Yoou are incredible! Thanks!

    my blog post web site

  11. [url=]accutane price[/url] [url=]finpecia tablet online[/url] [url=]levitra 20 mg daily[/url] [url=]buy kamagra india online[/url] [url=]generic dapoxetine online[/url] [url=]furosemide 100 mg tablets[/url] [url=]tadalafil tablets for sale[/url] [url=]buy over the counter xenical[/url] [url=]valtrex online pharmacy[/url] [url=]erythromycin brand name in usa[/url]

  12. [url=]how much is generic lipitor[/url] [url=]amoxicillin 500 mg[/url] [url=]singulair price[/url] [url=]avana online[/url] [url=]10 mg baclofen[/url]

  13. [url=]buy finpecia online[/url] [url=]buy amitriptyline[/url] [url=]celebrex 400 mg daily[/url] [url=]hydroxychloroquine for sale[/url] [url=]clonidine hydrochloride[/url] [url=]buspar 15[/url]

  14. [url=]buy vermox cheap[/url] [url=]buy levitra uk[/url] [url=]buy celebrex online[/url] [url=]doxycycline usa[/url] [url=]furosemide prescription medicine[/url] [url=]xenical generic[/url] [url=]buy amitriptyline[/url]

  15. [url=]generic kamagra uk[/url] [url=]buy silagra[/url] [url=]100mg baclofen[/url] [url=]albuterol ventolin[/url] [url=]hydroxychloroquine sulfate[/url] [url=]where can i buy vermox[/url] [url=]buy dapoxetine[/url] [url=]wellbutrin otc[/url] [url=]valtrex generic sale[/url] [url=]generic avana[/url]

  16. [url=]wellbutrin buy[/url] [url=]mebendazole price[/url] [url=]where to purchase tadalafil[/url] [url=]silagra generic[/url] [url=]buy doxycycline[/url] [url=]clonidine pill[/url] [url=]sildenafil tablets online australia[/url] [url=]buy ciprofloxacin online[/url] [url=]buy kamagra[/url] [url=]best price celebrex 200 mg[/url]

  17. [url=]buy amoxicillin online[/url] [url=]furosemide 40 mg[/url] [url=]hydroxychloroquine for sale[/url] [url=]finpecia[/url] [url=]ventolin 108[/url] [url=]sildenafil 100mg[/url]

  18. [url=]vermox 100 mg otc[/url] [url=]buy accutane[/url] [url=]medicine amitriptyline 25mg[/url] [url=]silagra 50 mg online[/url] [url=]purchase amoxicillin online[/url] [url=]buy hydroxychloroquine online[/url] [url=]wellbutrin 150 mg cost[/url] [url=]singulair prescription[/url]

  19. [url=]buy levitra[/url] [url=]where to get singulair in us[/url] [url=]buy celebrex[/url] [url=]drug doxycycline 100mg[/url] [url=]amitriptyline 25mg[/url] [url=]vermox cost uk[/url]

  20. [url=]baclofen tablets[/url] [url=]wellbutrin 191 pill[/url] [url=]singulair medicine[/url] [url=]sildenafil 50 mg tablet cost[/url] [url=]buspar rx[/url] [url=]dapoxetine tablets[/url] [url=]erythromycin medicine[/url] [url=]cymbalta duloxetine[/url] [url=]ventolin without prescription[/url] [url=]avana 31311[/url]

  21. [url=]ventolin hfa[/url] [url=]doxycycline drug[/url] [url=]ciprofloxacin 500mg[/url] [url=]cheapest on line valtrex without a prescription[/url] [url=]clonidine medication[/url] [url=]celebrex generic[/url]

  22. [url=]ciprofloxacin hcl[/url] [url=]where to buy levitra in singapore[/url] [url=]where can i buy ventolin online[/url] [url=]buy buspar[/url] [url=]amitriptyline cream buy[/url] [url=]how to buy priligy[/url] [url=]avana 77064[/url] [url=]xenical tablets[/url] [url=]valtrex 1g[/url] [url=]tadalafil cheap online[/url]

  23. [url=]buy valtrex[/url] [url=]buy levitra[/url] [url=]chloroquine us[/url] [url=]how much is clonidine[/url] [url=]buy erythromycin[/url] [url=]baclofen buy online[/url] [url=]cheap dapoxetine online[/url]

  24. Incredible all kinds of amazing knowledge! generic viagra 100mg [url=]d76kqvn l26lss[/url] 5355_e7

  25. 6e4721 viagra quel sit

    [url=]buy viagra[/url]

    buy viagra soft online canada

    [url=]cheap viagra[/url]

  26. 0bcc21 low price cialis sublingual uk

    [url=]cialis online[/url]

    everyday cialis

    [url=]cialis online[/url]

    generic cialis does work

    [url=]cialis online[/url]

  27. 7bfb21 cialis daily vs 36 hour

    [url=]cheap cialis online[/url]

    cialis pastillas

    [url=]cialis cheap[/url]

    online cialis side effects

    [url=]what does cialis do[/url]

  28. 5f7521 blueberry viagra

    [url=]viagra canada[/url]

    viagra spagna

    [url=]generic viagra[/url]

    cialis 20 mg 30 st

    [url=]cialis online[/url]

    cialis en el mundo

    [url=]buy cialis[/url]

  29. 1fd021 cialis online bestellen

    [url=]discount cialis[/url]

    education specialists

    [url=]cheap cialis online[/url]

    opinion generic cialis super

    [url=]buy cialis[/url]

    generic cialis to europe

    [url=]generic cialis online[/url]

  30. 0bcc21 i didnt do my assignment

    [url=]cheap viagra[/url]

    easy pay day loans ltd

    [url=]faxless payday advance[/url]

  31. 7bfb21 viagra nasal congestion

    [url=]buy viagra[/url]

    vendita viagra pis

    [url=]buy generic viagra[/url]

    viagra canada use

    [url=]viagra without a doctor prescription canada[/url]

  32. 383121 viagra e prostat

    [url=]viagra online[/url]

    we choice discount viagra sale

    [url=]buy viagra[/url]

    viagra online store

    [url=]viagra canada[/url]

    comprar viagra cialis barato

    [url=]viagra online[/url]

  33. 922221 sconti di cialis

    [url=]buy generic cialis[/url]

    cialis drug prescription

    [url=]generic cialis online[/url]

    programming assignment help

    [url=]discount viagra[/url]

    one year installment loans with bad credit

    [url=]faxless payday loan[/url]

  34. 097821 prices soft tab viagra

    [url=]online viagra[/url]

    viagra espaa venta


    acquisto viagra in inghilterra

    [url=]online viagra[/url]

    viagra by ranbaxy

    [url=]viagra online canadian pharmacy[/url]

  35. 0bcc21 online cialis daily

    [url=]cheap cialis[/url]

    cialis pricing canada

    [url=]canadian pharmacy cialis[/url]

  36. get a loan online with bad credit i need loan for business [url=]i need a loan[/url] need financial help urgently. payday loans online same day ed trial packs [url=]ed trial pack[/url] e mudra loan online apply, where to apply for loan online. need financial assistance for bills [url=]fed loans online payment 6000[/url] 8b948f9 need financial help moving, need a financial blessing, need financial help moving. online loans same day bad credit need financial help today, we need your financial help get a loan with bad credit online. need financial help for education title loans online texas, i need financial advice need financial help.

  37. Incredible all kinds of great information. what is a strong thesis statement
    [url=]e78kuta r24ixw[/url] 945352_

  38. I don’t know whether it’s just me or if perhaps everyone else encountering issues with your website.
    It seems like some of the written text within your posts
    are running off the screen. Can someone else please comment and let me know if this is happening to them too?

    This may be a problem with my web browser because I’ve had this happen previously.
    Thank you

  39. office software for mac download [url=]buy autocad[/url] software developer jobs 2020. 2020 software problem [url=]computer software download 2020 blog[/url] 554b1cb free office software pc, buy autocad 2020 software. office software best, apple office software free download 1506t new software 2020 download income tax software 2020 kerala. office software deals kss prasad it software 2020-21 download latest, free office software trial.

  40. Hey there would you mind letting me know which web host you’re utilizing?
    I’ve loaded your blog in 3 different web browsers and I must say this blog loads
    a lot faster then most. Can you suggest a good hosting provider at a fair price?
    Thanks, I appreciate it!

  41. Simply wish to say your article is as amazing.
    The clarity on your publish is just spectacular and that i
    can think you are a professional in this subject. Well along with your permission let me to clutch your feed
    to keep up to date with approaching post. Thanks 1,000,000 and please carry on the gratifying work.

  42. Great tips. Thanks! generic viagra without subscription [url=Щ…Ш­Щ…ШЇ-Ш§Щ„Щ‚Ш§Ш¶ЩЉ-ШЄШ±ЩѓЩЉШЁ-ШіЩЉШ±Ш§Щ…ЩЉЩѓ-ШЁЩ€Ш±ШіЩ„ЩЉЩ†-Ш±Ш®Ш§Щ…-ШЁШґШЄЩЉЩ„-Ш§Щ…ШЁШ§ШЁЩ‡-Ш§Щ„Ш¬ЩЉШІШ©-Ш§Щ…ШЁШ§ШЁЩ‡-Ш®ШЇЩ…Ш§ШЄ-Щ…Щ†ШІЩ„ЩЉШ©-ШµЩ†Ш§ЩЉШ№Щ‰-ШЈЩ€-ЩЃЩ†Щ‰-ШЄШ±ЩѓЩЉШЁ-ШіЩЉШ±Ш§Щ…ЩЉЩѓ-ШЇЩ„ЩЉЩ„-ШЈШ±ШІШ§Щ‚]r33gwor j21qry[/url] f931744

  43. I have been surfing on-line greater than three hours nowadays, yet I by no means discovered any attention-grabbing article like yours.

    It is pretty price sufficient for me. Personally, if all webmasters and
    bloggers made just right content as you did, the web
    will likely be much more helpful than ever before.

  44. I’ve been absent for some time, but now I remember why I used to love this website. Thanks, I will try and check back more often. How frequently you update your web site?

  45. wart treatment during pregnancy treating genital warts with duct tape. wart removal in foot warts removal during pregnancy [url=]best wart remover[/url] wart treatment on foot, wart on hand finger treatment. treating genital warts nhs treating warts on hand, treatment periungual warts. genital warts treatment in kenya, wart or zit treating genital warts with freeze away. genital warts treatment ebay treatment for a wart on finger, wart treatment doctor wart on finger home remedy. warts on cattle treatment, apple cider vinegar for feet warts. bioessence warts removal review, wart remover solid stick warts removal uk. wart treatment usa warts treatment pharmacy, wart treatment hong kong warts removal metrodeal. warts on face dream meaning, warts removal laser. treat plantar wart on foot [url=]treatment for genital warts in kenya udas[/url] 50_4c42 treatment for warts on hand. wart treatment on hands [url=]how do you treat warts on your hands i[/url] warts on face std warts removal vlog.

  46. You have made some good points there. I checked on the internet for additional information about the issue and found most individuals will go along with your views on this site.

  47. interest rates banks pay to borrow money i need loan from bank [url=]need a loan[/url] interest rate calculator on education loan. get a payday loan online no credit check dave cash advance reviews, interest rates banks pay to borrow money. apply for a loan online in nigeria [url=]get a payday loan online with bad credit 5000[/url] 058b948 loan and interest rate calculator, get a payday loan online today, interest rate calculator for business loan. borrow money low interest rate loans online cash advance app, getting a payday loan online online loans fast canada. interest rate calculator loan repayment get a loan online fast, borrowing money at negative interest rates get a loan online fast bad credit.

  48. I was recommended this blog by my cousin. I’m not sure whether this post
    is written by him as no one else know such detailed about my
    trouble. You’re amazing! Thanks!

  49. First off I want to say excellent blog! I had a quick question that I’d
    like to ask if you do not mind. I was interested to find out how you center
    yourself and clear your thoughts before writing. I have
    had a tough time clearing my mind in getting my thoughts
    out there. I truly do take pleasure in writing but it just seems like the
    first 10 to 15 minutes tend to be wasted simply just trying to figure out how to begin. Any recommendations or tips?
    doctors for cannabis regulation

  50. [url=]motilium otc[/url] [url=]generic buspar tablet[/url] [url=]tadalafil prescription us[/url]